The Lightkeeper's Daughters by Jean E Pendizwol

The Lighthouse Keeper’s Daughters My Rating: 3.6

Though her mind is still sharp, Elizabeth's eyes have failed. No longer able to linger over her beloved books or gaze at the paintings that move her spirit, she fills the void with music and memories of her family, especially her beloved twin sister, Emily. When her late father's journals are discovered after an accident, the past suddenly becomes all too present.

With the help of Morgan, a delinquent teenager performing community service at her senior home, Elizabeth goes through the diaries, a journey through time that brings the two women closer together. Entry by entry, these unlikely friends are drawn deep into a world far removed from their own, to Porphyry Island on Lake Superior, where Elizabeth's father manned the lighthouse and raised his young family 70 years before.

As the words on those musty pages come alive, Elizabeth and Morgan begin to realize that their fates are connected to the isolated island in ways they never dreamed. While the discovery of Morgan's connection sheds light onto her own family mysteries, the faded pages of the journals will shake the foundation of everything Elizabeth thinks she knows and bring the secrets of the past into the light.

While The Lighthouse Keeper’s Daughters kept me engaged and eager to discover the outcome, I found some aspects distracting. The frequent and often excessive swearing, from Morgan, felt jarring—especially in contrast to the sweet, elderly Elizabeth. Morgan could have been portrayed as strong, street-wise, or rebellious without relying so heavily on crude language, which seemed unlikely for a teenager in many scenes. Maybe it wouldn't have been so offensive it wasn't on audio where I was constantly hearing it.

Additionally, the story felt a bit long-winded at times and could have benefited from tighter editing. That said, the narrative was compelling enough that I stayed with it until the end. Overall, it’s a mixed experience: frustrating in style, but captivating in plot.